Mascara Base: Shiseido vs Dr. Mascara Fixer

~ stashy

Continuing with Lash Week, today I’ll be looking at mascara bases.  What is a mascara base?  It’s like a primer for your lashes.  I didn’t believe the hype until I received a gwp sample of the Shiseido, and then I became a convert.
mascarabase2
Late last year, I ordered a Korean mascara base by Etude House that had been highly reviewed online, which costs $9 each, vs $25 for the Shiseido one.  Let’s see how they stack up against each other.

I don’t wear false lashes, so I need all the help I can get with a mascara base. What a good mascara base does:
• enhances curled lashes
• helps build length and volume
• helps mascara to adhere to lashes better to prevent flaking and smudging
• some will even provide conditioning to the lashes

mascarabase4
Shiseido Nourishing Mascara Base is a cult favourite, and has been my HG staple for a few years now, and it checks all of the above attributes.  A tube with daily use will last me around 6 months (I’m quite surprised that for an eye product, the expiry on the product says 24 months after opening!)
mascarabase5
It has natural bristles that are quite short and fairly sparsely spaced so that it can get close to the roots of the lashes.  How I use the primer is as follows: I curl my lashes, then I apply a coat of the primer, let it dry for around 15 seconds, then apply my mascara on top as normal.  The primer applies clear and doesn’t make my lashes stiff.  The Shiseido performs brilliantly and I have no complaints – except that it’s quite pricey at $25 per tube.

The contender is Etude House Dr. Mascara Fixer – I bought both the Volume Up and the Longlash Up to try.  I’ve only opened the Volume version to use first (Longlash up has a curved wand).
mascarabase3
It also has natural bristles that are of average length with a tapered end, and the spacing of the bristles are slightly further apart compared to the Shiseido. The primer also applies clear.  It has a 6 month expiry after opening.
mascarabase6
I tested the Dr. Mascara Fixer for a week wearing my beloved L’Oreal Bare Naturale mascara on top.  Imagine my surprise when I noticed that the Dr. Mascara performed slightly better than the Shiseido!  I would say that in the area of building length or volume, it was on par with the Shiseido.  It also matched Shiseido for keeping my mascara from flaking and smudging.  The area where this base excelled was at holding my curl – it was quite impressive!
mascarabase7
A few other observations:
• Dr. Mascara Fixer claims it is “infused with Black Food extracts to condition lashes”; Shiseido also touts lash conditioning as an attribute. I don’t relay on my mascara base for this – I use my trusty Cargo LashActivator Night (or soon to be caster oil) for helping my lashes stay healthy.
• I didn’t notice any difference between how the 2 wand styles applied their respective products.
• Maybe it’s just me, but I really like mascaras that come in these squeeze lipgloss type tubes – I feel like I can get more product out of the tube.
• The only downside to Dr. Mascara Fixer is that I can only buy it online whereas I have easy access to Shiseido

Overall, I’m very pleased I took a chance and tried the Etude House Mr. Mascara Fix base.  I’ll be buying this from now on!  I can’t wait to try the Longlash version.  Saving $16 on every tube is a no brainer.

Other mascara bases that I’ve used before that I haven’t liked as much:
• Clinique Lash Building Primer ($19) – makes my lashes droop
• DiorShow Maximizer Lash Plumping Serum & Primer ($35) – good for volumizing but tend to give lashes a spidery appearance, also very expensive

Do you use mascara bases?  What is your favourite?

38 thoughts on “Mascara Base: Shiseido vs Dr. Mascara Fixer”

  3. I’ve never tried using a mascara base before, honestly i didn’t even know such not until I read your post. Hurray for Etude! My fingers are crossed while reading your verdict. Please, let it be Etude! 😭
    I also have pin straight lashes and I believe this is a life changing product.

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply

  4. I’ve only ever tried the Urban Decay one. Not the new one that came out with their Perversion mascara, but the old one from a few years ago. I was not impressed with it.

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply

  7. The only one I’ve tried is from MAC, but only because I was hoping it would help my mascara not smudge. Didn’t work out. That’s awesome that the budget brand worked better!

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply
  9. Pingback: Trash Stash: May 2015 | stash matters
  10. Pingback: Best of 2015 discoveries | stash matters
  11. Pingback: Lash Week Round-up from 2015 | stash matters
  12. Pingback: What I’m Bringing to Japan (Travel Makeup) | stash matters
  13. Pingback: Trash Stash: May & June 2016 | stash matters
  14. Pingback: Trash Stash: April 2016 | stash matters
  15. Pingback: My Very First Jolse Order | stash matters
  16. Pingback: Trash Stash: September and October 2016 | stash matters
  17. Pingback: Korean Beauty Haul: Holika Holika, Etude House, Clio | stash matters

  18. I’m intrigued!! I’ll put this on my wish list! I currently have a few lonely mascaras in my bin that I’m avoiding because they smudge or flake. Hopefully the Etude House base will fix them!!

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply

    1. I hope you try this – it makes a huge difference for me with mascaras that aren’t stellar. Make sure you get the Perfect Lash one (straight wand), not the Length one (curved wand) – the Length one has nasty fibres in it that were so irritating.

      Liked by 1 person

      Reply
  19. Pingback: Trash Stash: January 2017 | stash matters

  20. I thought mascara primers were a superfluous gimmick product until I received one in a GWP and tried It. I have used Clinique and Estee Lauder with great success. They make my lashes significantly longer than with mascara alone. No matter the brand, I have always had a problem with mascara splattering on my eyelids, even though I wipe the brush before applying and apply slowly and carefully. Primer alleviates this problem: no more splatters. It gives the mascara something to adhere to. Mascara primers is now a must have product for me.

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply

    1. I always thought mascara bases were gimmick too but they do make a huge difference on any mascara that I put on top. For me, they hold a curl and help to reduce flaking and smudges. I often wonder why don’t mascaras just have built-in primers instead? 😛

      Like

      Reply
  21. Pingback: My Current Holy Grail Beauty Products | stash matters

    1. I just found this comment. Sorry!
      Yes, I did end up trying the other version, the Longlash and I hated it! It contains these THICK black fibres that were so irritating to my eyes. Have a look:

      I mention it in this empties post:

      Trash Stash: May & June 2016

      Which mascara base do you use now? I recall you tried both the Dr Mascara and also the Shiseido and liked both.

      Liked by 1 person

      Reply

      1. Omg yes!! I have this EXACT SAME PROBLEM with that particular Dr Mascara Fixer! It’s so annoying and gross – I find myself having to wipe it every now and again cos I can’t stand how disgusting and gunky it looks!

        I’m still currently (kinda) using the long lash Dr Mascara but it’s really time for me to part with it. I like how clean the Shiseido one is but I’m not sure it’s something I can purchase all the time?

        Like

        Reply
  23. Pingback: Trash Stash 2017 Summary | stash matters

    1. Oh really? Shiseido discontinued their mascara base? How silly of them. It was one of the first makeup items I ever tried from Shiseido. I highly recommend the Dr Mascara Volume Up version with the pink lettering as a replacement. You can buy it off Amazon or Jolse. Don’t get the Longlash Up version – it has thick black fibres that are irritating to the eyes.

      Like

      Reply

Leave a Comment: